I know we've had at least a few discussions about the repercussions of the digital age. Personally, I believe there are a great deal of things that have arisen from the digital age that I love. The
Internet allows me easy access to a great deal of information that I otherwise would not have the time or energy to research. Email and cell phones allow me to keep in touch with friends and family back home (Wisconsin) much easier than would otherwise be possible. Though admittedly, I am terrible at keeping in touch with people despite that, as I'm often reminded. One thing that really irks me about digital information, though, is this movement to replace books and magazines with 'e-materials.'
I hate e-books and e-zines, and the like, for a number of reasons, and particularly when I have to pay for them. I'm a Dungeons and Dragons fan, and have been since late elementary school. For those of you who don't know what that is, I'll explain as briefly as I can. You've heard of World of Warcraft or Everquest? Well, Dungeons and Dragons is the basis for those games. Instead of playing it on a computer, however, Dungeons and Dragons is played with pencil and paper and, most importantly, imagination, at a table with a group of your friends. Well, Dungeons and Dragons requires a good many books to play, instead of CDs with expansions for WOW or Everquest and the like. Wizards of the Coast, the publisher of D&D, used to publish a pair of magazines named, respectively, Dungeon and Dragon. Original, I know, but they were great publications! Dragon contained information to help the players create better characters. Dungeon detailed adventures for those players to participate in from start to finish. Well, recently, WotC decided to cancel the publication of these magazines and move them onto their website as ezines. I was a little miffed about this. I've been collecting these magazines nearly since I started playing the game. But I tried not to get too up in arms about it, because the information was being released for free from the website.
Well, today I logged on to look at the new articles published, and I found out that I now must pay $7 per issue of each magazine in order to view the content. For those too lazy to do the math, and I don't blame you, that's $168 for access to all 24 issues that will be published in the next year. $168 for something that I can't even take away from my computer!
Now, the costs aside, I hate this movement to digitize books and magazines for other reasons. I like to pick up and feel the books I'm reading. I like to fill my bookshelves with all the volumes I've collected. My wife and I have three bookshelves bursting with books, and most of those are double stacked because we don't have room for more shelves. I keep my Dragon and Dungeon magazines in protectors in binders, organized by date of publication. I like to write notes in the margins of my books and make marks when I find something interesting. I like the feel of the paper of old books, and I love the smell of old libraries. I used volunteer my time in an old elementary library, I loved organizing and categorizing the books (I liked reading children's stories to the classes that came in, but that's beside the point). I like carrying books in my backpack and being able to whip one out to read when I have nothing better to do. Perhaps that's a materialistic attachment but there's just something about holding a good book in your hands, rather than bringing up some ethereal file on your harddrive that could perish with a particularly nasty virus or power surge.
So I leave you with a quote from the character Rupert Giles, from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (I know I'm a geek, it goes without saying): "Books smell musty and rich. The knowledge gained from a computer... It has no texture, no context. It's there and then it's gone. If it's to last, then the getting of knowledge should be tangible. It should be, uh... smelly."
What do you think?